Get a Quote
By Ryan Cox
Director, Allied Consumer Moving
Read More

Should I Self-Move vs. Hire a Mover? 

Deciding whether to self-move or hire a mover is a common dilemma faced by many when planning a move. Both options have their pros and cons, and ultimately, the choice depends on your priorities, budget, and personal preferences. We will explore the factors to consider when making this crucial decision.

When considering a self-move, you might be drawn to the potential cost savings and the ability to control the entire process. This option allows you to have full oversight of your belongings and the flexibility to move at your own pace. Remember that self-moving can be physically demanding and time-consuming, especially for those with a lot of items or who are moving long distances.

On the other hand, hiring movers offers a more convenient and less stressful approach to the moving process. Professional moving companies have the expertise and equipment necessary to efficiently and safely transport your belongings. While this option may come with a higher price tag, the peace of mind and reduction in manual labor can make it worth the cost for many individuals.

As you weigh the pros and cons of self-moving versus hiring professional movers, you should evaluate your individual needs, preferences, and budget to determine the best course of action for your moving experience.

Understanding the Concept of Self Moving and Hiring a Mover

In this section, we will explore the concepts of self-moving and hiring a mover to help you make an informed decision while planning your next move.

Concept of Self Move

A self-move, or DIY move, is when you take it upon yourself to handle all aspects of the moving process. This includes packing your belongings, renting a moving truck, loading and unloading, and driving the truck to your new location. Some benefits of self-moving include:

  • Cost savings: Typically, self-moving is more affordable compared to hiring a moving company. Renting a moving truck can range from $120 to $200 for local moves or $1,500 to $2,300 for long-distance moves.

  • Control and flexibility: With a self-move, you can control the entire process and manage your own time, ensuring that your belongings are handled with care.

  • Smaller moves: If you have fewer belongings to transport, self-moving might be more manageable and efficient.

However, keep in mind that self-moving can be physically demanding and time-consuming, especially if you are not experienced with packing and driving a large moving truck.

Concept of Hiring a Mover

Hiring a professional moving company involves paying for their expertise and services to handle all aspects of your move. These services may include packing, disassembling, and reassembling furniture, loading, and unloading, and transportation. Some benefits of hiring a mover include:

  • Less physical effort: Professional movers are trained to handle heavy and large items, reducing the physical strain on you.

  • Time savings: Hiring a moving company allows you to focus on other aspects of your move, such as logistics and settling into your new home.

  • Insurance: Moving companies usually offer coverage for your possessions in case of damage or loss.

  • Efficiency: Professional movers are experienced in packing and using moving equipment, increasing the efficiency of the move.

While hiring a mover can be more expensive than self-moving, it can save you time and effort, making the process less stressful.

Your decision to self-move or hire a mover will depend on factors such as your budget, the size of your move, and your personal preferences. Consider the pros and cons of each option to determine the most suitable choice for your specific needs.

Factors to Consider When Moving

When deciding whether to move or hire a mover, there are several important aspects to take into account. In this section, we will discuss the factors to consider when moving, including cost, time, distance, location, planning, and scheduling.

Cost Factors

Moving can be expensive, and your budget will likely play a significant role in your decision. Consider the costs of renting a moving truck, fuel, packing material, and any additional equipment, such as a dolly, if necessary. Compare these expenses to the quotes from professional moving companies. While hiring a mover can be more costly upfront, it might save you time, energy, and potential damage to your belongings.

Time Considerations

Take into account the amount of time you have to dedicate to your move. A DIY move might require more time for packing, loading, driving, and unloading compared to hiring a professional moving company that can handle these tasks efficiently. Moving yourself might also mean taking time off work, adding another cost factor to consider.

Distance and Location Factors

The distance between your current and new home plays a role in your moving decision. Short-distance moves might be easier to handle by yourself, but long-distance moves can be more taxing, especially when driving a large truck or making multiple trips. Additionally, factor in the accessibility and logistics of each location, such as navigating tight spaces, parking restrictions, or dealing with stairs.

Planning and Schedule Considerations

When planning a move, the complexity, season, and scheduling factors come into play. Is your move simple, or does it involve large, fragile, or valuable items? Hiring professionals can offer peace of mind and expertise in handling such items. Moreover, consider the season you're moving; for example, moving during the winter months can be more difficult due to harsh weather conditions.

Furthermore, evaluate the flexibility of your schedule. If you're working with a tight timeline or have specific requirements, hiring a mover might be beneficial as they can work within your constraints and manage the logistics more efficiently.

In the end, each moving scenario is unique, so carefully consider these factors to make the best choice for your situation.

Pros and Cons of Both Options

Pros and Cons of Self-Moving

Pros of Self-Moving:

  • Control: When you move yourself, you have total control over the entire moving process. You can choose the truck, all moving supplies, and handle the moving boxes to ensure nothing breaks.
  • Flexibility: Self-moving gives you the opportunity to set your own schedule and work at your own pace, making it easier to accommodate last-minute changes.
  • Cost-effective: Moving yourself can be more affordable, as you avoid the fees associated with hiring a professional moving company.

Cons of Self-Moving:

  • Stress: Self-moving can be stressful, as you are responsible for each aspect of the move, including packing, loading, driving the moving truck, and unloading.
  • Efficiency: It may take longer to move on your own, especially if you lack experience with packing and organizing your belongings.
  • Physical exertion: Self-moving requires significant physical effort, which can be tiring and potentially lead to injury if proper precautions are not taken.

Pros and Cons of Hiring a Mover

Pros of Hiring a Mover:

  • Efficiency: Professional movers have the skills and expertise to complete the job quickly, saving you time and energy.
  • Peace of mind: Hiring a mover allows you to focus on other tasks associated with the move, reducing stress and providing peace of mind.
  • Safety: Professional movers have the tools, equipment, and experience to handle heavy or fragile items, reducing the risk of damage or injury.

Cons of Hiring a Mover:

  • Cost: Hiring a moving company usually costs more than self-moving, which might not be an option for those on a tight budget.
  • Control: When you hire a mover, you relinquish some control over the moving process, as professionals will handle packing, loading, and unloading the truck.
  • Availability: You may have to work around the mover's schedule, which might not always align with your preferred timeline, and you could face delays in service or delivery.

Packing and Loading Process

Packing and Loading in Self-Moving

When you choose to self-move, you are responsible for packing and loading your belongings. This allows for more flexibility in how you pack and load your items, as well as potentially saving money. Here are some things to consider when packing and loading for a self-move:

  • Packing: You can pack your belongings however you prefer. Be prepared to purchase packing supplies such as boxes, bubble wrap, packing tape, and labeling materials. Make sure to pack heavy items in small boxes while distributing weight evenly in larger boxes.
  • Heavy Lifting: In a self-move, you need to be prepared for heavy lifting, especially when handling furniture and heavy boxes. Consider enlisting help from friends or family members to avoid injury.
  • Loading: When loading your possessions into a moving truck or personal vehicle, take time to ensure that everything is properly secured and evenly distributed. Use straps or ropes to tie down large items and prevent movement during transit.

Packing and Loading When Hiring Mover

If you decide to hire a professional moving company, the packing and loading process becomes much more streamlined. Below are some advantages of hiring movers to help with packing and loading:

  • Professional Packing: Movers have the training and expertise to properly pack your fragile and valuable items. They know the best techniques for wrapping delicate glassware, disassembling dining room furniture, and packing large artwork or mirrors.
  • No Heavy Lifting: Hiring movers eliminates the need for you to do the heavy lifting. The moving team will safely handle your furniture and heavy boxes, reducing the risk of injury.
  • Efficient Loading: A professional moving crew knows how to strategically load your belongings into a moving truck, maximizing space and ensuring everything is well-secured for transportation. This can save both time and effort on your part.

By having a clear understanding of the packing and loading process in both self-moving and hiring a professional mover, you can make a more informed decision on which option suits your needs best.

Cost Considerations

When deciding whether to move yourself or hire a professional mover, cost is an important factor to consider. This section focuses on the financial aspects of both options, divided into two subsections: one for self-moving and one for hiring a mover.

Cost Considerations in Self-Moving

In self-moving, you are responsible for all aspects of the move, which can include truck rental, packing supplies, and fuel expenses. Here is a breakdown of some costs:

  • Truck rental: Depending on the size of the truck, rental costs generally range from $120 to $200 for a local move or $1,500 to $2,300 for a long-distance move.
  • Packing supplies: You'll need to purchase boxes, bubble wrap, and packing tape, which can add up quickly. Consider looking for free supplies, like used boxes, to save money.
  • Fuel: You'll need to cover gas expenses for the moving truck. Keep in mind the size and weight of the truck; larger vehicles are less fuel-efficient and can result in higher fuel costs.
  • Additional expenses: There may be extra costs associated with self-moving, such as:
    • Renting a dolly to move heavy items
    • Purchasing food and beverages for helpers
    • Potential lodging and meals if your move takes multiple days

Cost Considerations When Hiring a Mover

When hiring a professional mover, costs will typically include the following:

  • Rate: Moving companies typically charge by the hour or based on the weight of your belongings. 
  • Estimates and quotes: To determine the cost of your move, request estimates from several movers to compare their proposed rates. Keep in mind that these are just estimates, and the final cost may differ.
  • Insurance: Most moving companies offer basic insurance coverage, which may be insufficient for valuable belongings. You might need to purchase additional coverage or rely on your homeowners' insurance for protection.
  • Extra fees: Professional movers may have additional charges for services such as packing, disassembling furniture, and handling oversized items. Make sure to review the contract in detail and clarify any additional fees before signing.

Overall, the costs of both self-moving and hiring a mover can vary greatly depending on your specific needs and preferences. It's important to carefully evaluate your budget and the complexity of your move to make the right decision for you.

Experience and Skills Required

Skills Required for Self-Moving

When self-moving, there are several skills you should have to ensure a smooth relocation process:

  • Packing expertise: You need to know how to pack your belongings efficiently and securely to prevent damage during transit.
  • Physical strength: Moving heavy items like furniture and appliances require physical strength and endurance.
  • Organization skills: Planning and proper organization are essential to minimize stress and last-minute complications.
  • Driving a large vehicle: Navigating a moving truck may pose challenges, especially in tight spaces or busy traffic.

Keep in mind that moving by yourself can be labor-intensive, time-consuming, and potentially risky if you're inexperienced.

Experience and Skills of Professional Movers

Hiring professional movers brings several advantages due to their experience and skills:

  • Trained packers: Professionals are skilled in packing various items, from fragile valuables to bulky furniture pieces, ensuring their safety during transport.
  • Efficient loading and unloading: Movers have the know-how to load and unload your belongings swiftly while minimizing the risk of damage or injury.
  • Equipment and resources: Professional movers have access to tools, equipment, and moving trucks designed for different types of moves.
  • Insurance coverage: In case anything goes wrong, reputable moving companies provide coverage for damages and losses.

By hiring professionals, you can largely reduce the physical and mental strain associated with the moving process, ensuring a more efficient and stress-free relocation.

Safety Considerations

When deciding whether to move yourself or hire a mover, safety is a crucial factor to consider. Both options have their own safety concerns, which may differ depending on the specific situation. In this section, we will discuss safety issues in self-moving and hiring a mover.

Safety in Self-Moving

When moving yourself, there are several safety considerations to keep in mind:

  • Lifting: Improper lifting techniques can lead to injuries, such as strains and sprains. When lifting heavy objects, bend your knees and use your legs, not your back. Keep the load close to your body to avoid putting extra strain on your spine.
  • Packing: Overpacking boxes can cause them to become heavy and difficult to lift or move safely. Distribute weight evenly among multiple boxes and clearly label each box with its contents and weight to avoid potential injuries.
  • Navigating: Moving heavy objects in tight spaces or up and down stairs can be challenging and lead to accidents. Make sure you have a clear path and use proper lifting techniques to minimize injuries.
  • Planning: Moving safely requires planning and organization. Coordinate with friends or family members to help and ensure everyone is aware of their role in the move.

Safety When Hiring Mover

When hiring a mover, your safety concerns may shift:

  • Reputation: Research the mover's reputation and customer reviews to ensure they have a track record of being reliable, professional, and safety-conscious.
  • Experience: Experienced movers will be more knowledgeable about proper moving techniques, reducing the risk of accidents and injuries.
  • Equipment: Professional movers should have the necessary equipment, such as dollies and moving straps, to move bulky items safely and efficiently.

To maximize safety when deciding between self-moving or hiring a mover, weigh the benefits and risks associated with each option and make a choice that best aligns with your needs and abilities.

When it comes to the decision of whether to move by yourself or hire a professional mover, it ultimately depends on your unique situation and priorities. You should consider several key factors in your planning, including budget, time, and effort required in both options.